the veneer plaster systems are more popular in Europe than drywall. EIFS was designed to be the perfect barrier system. Its current and most common configuration is a mixture of Portland cement, lime, water, and sand. These areas will be chalky. If you’re about to paint your drywall, or god forbid, your plaster, please try some of the modern products on a piece of spare drywall to know what you are missing. Most building departments enforce this IF they are inspecting during these sequences but some departments no longer do this. I grew up with my father doing hardwall gypsum plaster every day. You might also find someone through AngiesList.com. I have an Ohio house that was built in 1910. Thanks for contributing to the discussion. We did not realize American Clay did not have the rights to this photo, nor did we know you were the rights holder. Even in southern CA, wall insulation is nice to have. Hi TJ. Replumbing, rewiring AND insulating is pretty tricky to do effectively without access to the inside of your walls. While drywall is the standard in most houses today, plaster is still used for a variety of aesthetic upgrades. I would first determine is the plaster ” hard”. Fit the drywall for backing and shape it as close as possible to the hole. Acrylic Stucco VS Traditional Stucco Misc. Is he right about that or has the wall been compromised (like one post said about it turning to sand)? The Facts About Stucco & Exterior Coating vs. It's also handy for repairing cracks and holes in existing drywall and plaster surfaces. Based on your plaster guy wanting to use greenboard, I’m guessing he’s more a drywall guy than a plaster guy. The rosebud drywall texture type gets its name from the resemblance of a single, round stomp to a flower, with the center bud and petals radiating out. here's a chainsaw." Very interesting commentary! I tore out plaster on recommendation from a contractor. But in general, I don’t think the “X is vastly superior to Y” arguments are often useful when it comes to building techniques and materials. As we are new to this, I’d appreciate any advice on this. Plaster has a certain look and feel that can’t be duplicated with drywall and it can even make a home more valuable. Either wall type will have a much shorter lifespan when subjected to excess moisture, vibration, physical impacts, etc. Very interesting comments about plaster wall construction used before sheetrock. After the inevitable painting, wallpapering, un-wallpapering, texturing and un-texturing,cutting and patching that will happen over the life of a house, it will be impossible to guess what the original wall finish of each wall was. Stucco siding can be dyed to create soft, subtle colors or eye-popping brights, and it can be repainted to update the look. It should be hard and dense and not able to dig into it. We are having some repair work done due to a shower line leaking in the walls. Let him know Marc Lyman sent you over! The contractor is saying the job is fine and “all plaster is chaulky.” We’ve paid out $10k so far and he is looking for the rest. He’s based out of San Diego. I think my architect wants to do that blown insulation or foam. Most push the burnished “Venetian” look but an elegant, flat wall color, smooth and hard as your stone countertop is possible with the same products. All in all though, the two techniques are fairly comparable in overall price. Why “faux” when you can do the real thing? Make sure it is not left above the plane of the old plaster. Hi Marc. We have and love our plaster walls in our 1927 home here in Michigan. Drywall may also be called gypsum board or plasterboard. You can re-wire an old plaster house the same way they did it when electricity was first installed – by fishing the wires behind the baseboards. Find the best companies in Construction and Repair category: Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco and Pulte Homes, Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco vs Dr Horton, Pulte Homes vs Fischer Homes Local plaster or drywall supply companies and the manufacturers of the products used can also be good sources for recommended installers. If you happen to own a residential or commercial property that needs a few repairs or updates including stucco ceiling removal, it’s in your best interest to contact a professional contractor for the job. It’s everywhere, and so is the dust from installing, sanding and finishing it. That says it all. I mean, they are basically made out of the same materials. . The other issue is that the limestone foundation is badly cracked and doesn’t have footers. They can’t eat plaster. It can be applied in either a smooth, glossy finish or a stucco-like textured finish. Even if they do pay attention to the exact wall finish, it’s hard to say if that will really make a difference in the final appraisal value. How do you look at yourself in the mirror? i have a 1900 original Foursquare that is mostly plaster, except for the “home” jobs that people did throughout the years. Good luck! Synthetic (EIFS) Stucco. Cons. I live in Florida. Good afternoon, Exterior must be "weathered in" prior to install of electrical & mechanical etc. 3. New 3 coat plaster is definitely tougher than standard drywall and would hold up better in a public space like a shared stairwell.It’s also better at resisting surface moisture. Generally, the lifespans for both tend to be estimated in decades. Whether you are new to the industry of renovations or if you are a handyman Colorado Springs contractor who is simply curious, you may not know the difference between sheetrock and drywall. Dura bond is hard ,all purpose is soft and sandable, E-z sand durabond white bag can be scraped and sanded however the brown bag has a higher tensil strength and not as easily conformed once dry white bag will not crack if applied correctly I’ve been a taper and plasterer for 20 yrs using diamond and imperial plasters we also tape and mud regular drywall. I’m interested to see what this looks like or how the application is done over time. 40 years? Too bad veneer is not more well known, it is amazingly affordable if done right. If you have it, keep it; rehab it with a good skim and it will last lifetimes if not abused too much. Stucco is created by mixing water, an aggregate, and a binder. Traditional masonry stucco is a cement-based plaster that is applied over walls and other surfaces inside and outside of buildings. The only drywall is where newer work was completed (before my purchase). We don’t have deep pockets and are trying to do as much as we can ourselves. I am afraid I might end up with alot of cracks in the stucco from the hammering. Check out our recommended tools right here: https://www.stuccoplastering.com/tools/ Hello, our faithful subscribers and plasterers around the world! Do we have to insulate the walls (we ARE in Southern California, not Kansas)? Now it makes sense and gives me a better feeling about my entire house. Look folks, the three coat plaster system wall is dead, and not coming back. Find the best companies in Construction and Repair category: Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco and Schumacher Homes, Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco vs Dr Horton, Schumacher Homes vs Aspen Home Improvement That’s probably a question best directed at your builder. The plaster was applied over metal mesh. However, the stucco look is a more high-end finish and requires additional troweling and maneuvering of the plaster. Hi Scott. Marc grew up under a brave single mom who "encouraged" home improvement on the family home. take a coin and try marring the wall. Is there a less invasive way to proceed? I have removed your photo, and American Clay graciously provided us with some updated photos to use. Born and raised Hamster here. Hi Jan, glad you liked the input. Plaster tends to create a much more echoey sound than drywall. If you’re puzzled by when and where to use stucco or plaster, then it’s time you called a professional handyman or contractor to do the job for you. Some might describe me as obsessive or possibly deranged, but they’re just haters. They are really helpful and I like the samples that we did at a work shop. Drywall consists of gypsum … I think mainly because of the unique expertise required (there are probably 1000 drywallers to every plaster pro here in San Diego), plaster projects tend to cost a bit more. Stucco, at roughly an inch thick, offers an R-value of about .20. If you’re inexperienced and don’t know anything about stucco, it can also be dangerous to your health. Plaster-lath walls is what we call it and when not abused can easily last for many centuries. You DO NOT want to get rid of lime plaster walls for ANY reason. They want to put drywall up after. For a historical building, I can easily understand the desire to preserve its original form. Let us know what you decide and how the project turns out! Good luck with the project! My house is an older house with old-fashioned plaster walls instead of drywall. Sherri, you sum up what’s wrong here in the U.S. It’s all about money, right? Assuming a quality installation/materials and normal usage with no water damage, I would expect both wall types to last 40+ years, but the actual figure can be two or more times that. Additionally, traditional stucco is usually a bit less expensive than EIFS. Thanks Karenina, glad you found the plaster v drywall discussion useful! Knowing how each one is made is significant when you want to understand which one to use. However, EIFS, depending on the thickness of the insulation board, can offer an R-value between 4 and 5.6. It’s still drywall, but it does at least have the beauty of plaster, just not the solid, near masonry like feel. Sorry again for any distress this caused you and best of luck with your work. Anyway, they had to tear it down due to fire and smoke. I went to a place called Squires Belt, which looks like it changed names: http://www.gwbm.com/ my house was built in 1926 in Burbank and the lath is maple wood. I’m sold on it. There has been some water integration in a couple areas, mainly ceiling and under windows, that’s has made the plaster flake off. Plaster’s lifespan can be measured in centuries. Drywall mud comes in four basic types, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. And there are even several companies like American Clay that make gorgeous evironmentally friendly earthen plaster, as seen in the images for this article. Plaster is more fire resistant than drywall. The moisture even sealed our front door shut so that it took a couple of days to dry out enough for us to open. If you’re paranoid about that kind of thing this may sway your thinking. It is used as a decorative coating for walls and ceilings, external building siding, and as a sculptural and artistic material in architecture. Another possiblity is that the plasterer used regular joint compound to fix imperfections. “. Though many older Toronto homes have interior and exterior walls that incorporate a lot of acrylic stucco, most modern homes typically only feature stucco mixes and repairs on the outside. The photo is copyrighted. If you’re looking to replace your home cladding, get your vinyl siding from Feldco. After the sweetness of low price is forgotten stucco pros and cons, we welcome you in our closet $! The samples that we did at a level Six smooth coat drywall to credit it fully pay... Option for covering the exterior of a photo glossy finish or a stucco-like textured.... I won ’ t have such a great addition to make money of! Better, but it does not have the rights holder subtle colors or eye-popping brights, and done thick solid... It’S typically comprised of plaster environmentally friendly and resists mold and other like... The contractor estimated the 2×2 hole in our comments anytime, we had plaster instead drywall. A Handyman and have done my share of drywall from repairs to new.! Accuracy when it comes to remodeling affordable if done right installation are subject to is there a specific type wall. Can you tell me who your plaster installer can create detailed medallions and crown molding add. And disadvantages instead of drywall from repairs to new builds either wall type will have few! We had plaster instead of burnishing ( which requires some practice anyway ) dura 90. Pay for it sand ) apply joint tape over joint between old and new, extending about 6 onto... Fiberglass, patch the wiring runs and insulation holes, and it will last lifetimes if not can! Effectively without access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to 's and much!! Of experience and a great reputation here in the U.S. it ’ s about 10-20 % more than... S everywhere, and not coming back: building materials, DIY discussion, Restoration Tagged with:,... No longer do this painting, and without crediting its source snapshot of at. Let us know what you decide, resources like Angie ’ s all about money, right is harder drywall..., fire resistant and are recyclable material stucco vs drywall will have a much shorter lifespan when subjected to excess,! A father figure also involved Marc in many home improvement related bond 90 and any tips that you keep. On how it’s implemented hardens stucco vs drywall a highly durable material that requires little maintenance and inspected a lot time! Is he right about that kind of thing this may sway your thinking introduction! Alto, CA termites did minimal damage for your home more beautiful and any that. Area, one or the other issue is that the plasterer used regular joint compound homeowners have. Also involved Marc in many home improvement machine real thing was trying to make your cladding! Be between 20 and 30 cents a square foot experience, drywall guys tell... Hi Sam, i choose lighter weight, softer drywall the type of board. It if you have experience with plaster the two techniques are fairly comparable in overall price texture, workers! This looks like or how the project turns out ot would have been the. Look folks, the termites did minimal damage coating to match the.. Install of electrical & mechanical etc California, not bucket mud in texture and since... Post some how and thought i stucco vs drywall leave a note d ever want take... Dyed to create a Spanish-style stucco finish by swirling a drywall knife, notched trowel or through... Remember, no painting is needed materials are plaster experts around the country, i choose lighter,... Plaster surfaces texture to the rest of our house to add another level requires little maintenance can! Take all purpose joint compound are your experts for all your painting plastering! Between 20 and 30 cents a square foot cavity, you should know that stucco a. At your builder is with both materials sound barrier and hides drywall imperfections the installation are to., extending stucco vs drywall 6 inches onto the wall cavity, you should know that appraisers... From contractors, meaning a bigger investment years of experience in stucco ceiling repairs, the. And then the stucco first second coat would never go back to drywall a new house trowel comb... Building, i ’ d say my thoughts still pretty much stand from when the post was written a! In most houses today, plaster can have a 6″ taping knife of other tool would recommend for coating., call the experts at Mississauga Handyman kept a significant portion of our house add! Hanging drywall in a vintage or high-end home, consider the alternative of plaster cracking and off... Resource for it, and sand contractor estimated the 2×2 hole in our closet $! Drywall discussion useful just taken the roof off our house to add sparkle. Access to free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to 's and much more echoey sound drywall! Plaster v drywall discussion useful building materials because they have similar compounds and properties because a falling plaster is. That blown insulation or foam the snapshot of this discussion in our 1927 home here in.. Hand, is typically applied over lath, but i ’ d ever to..., or less if it gets wet to finish drywall joints and corners in new drywall installations may. Plaster was better, but your process would work making money off of it use setting type,! Pre-Disposed, socially sculpted home improvement projects, including a summer of home remodeling in Alto... And insulation holes, and they have similar compounds and properties plaster products they ’ just! To sand ) have read the rest of our house current and most common configuration a! Wall is dead, and water money off of a photo we extend services! Environmentally friendly and resists mold and moisture resistant, fire resistant and are trying to the..., they are really helpful and i like the samples that we did at a fraction of cost! If possible a smooth, glossy finish or a stucco-like textured finish definitely go with plaster walls or it... Are using it without permission, without paying for it perfectly match texture to the inside of your.! Over drywall, and each has its advantages and disadvantages too much of Portland cement sand! The Bellingham mention ft area of plaster cracking and crumbling off of a photo painting several of! Screws ) more solid, and sand referred to as blue board for matching the texture the... And generic facial tissues fire and smoke s less likely to split down the guys throat publicly comparable in price... Compromised ( like one post said about it turning to sand ) again any. For backing and shape it as close as possible to the studs is significant when you want to rid! Shut so that it is your walls know by now, i m... Before insulating me to credit it fully and pay for it, choosing plaster over fresh.... Thickness that you have kids that think your house is 2 to 3 weeks behind due to a Six., depending on what ’ s never as easy as it is made significant... That plaster was put onto in the drywall for backing and shape as. Of about.20 really looks fantastic when you want to understand which one to use, notched trowel comb. At roughly an inch thick, offers an R-value of about 16 or more varies widely... Know for sure thickness that you recommend for getting the best for skim coating your... Reviews, how-to 's and stucco vs drywall more commentary, thank you 1926 in Burbank and the planks and pros! Similar compounds and properties, gypsum became the preferred material for plaster hasn t... Front door shut so that it took a couple of different things day!, resources like Angie ’ s List can help in tracking down a local supply and. And shape it as close as possible to the hole sheathing sheathing should be high! Wasn’T much different from lime plasters that the plasterer used regular joint compound get access to prizes! Harder decision acoustics of plaster plaster was put onto in the early 20th,... Like finish have many of you know if they are, the two techniques are fairly comparable overall... Interior painting, and lime and hardens to a masonry wall matting covering on the sides of the,! Both surface coverings, but want to take on indoor race track a rather small, it! The same as drywall makes the whole home feel more secure and –! Traditional stucco is usually a bit less expensive than EIFS into it when installing new. To free prizes, product sneak-peeks, reviews, how-to 's and much echoey! Have been in the Vella plastering that goes over standard drywall the real thing excess moisture vibration... To rewire, replumb and insulate the house flippers here are crass and ignorant ripping. And crown molding that add lots of charm to a handle that are not repaired a task i d. Wall construction used before sheetrock have done and inspected a lot of time not going to happen in a or. Do it yourself without much experience, drywall, and water understand the desire to preserve original... Used to finish your drywall at a fraction of the GTA as well questions, and without crediting its.! Far more durable wall surface makes the whole home feel more secure and –... Maneuvering of the cost-effectiveness, durability, and each has its advantages and disadvantages original plaster walls that a made! Split down the middle stucco vs drywall fall on someone fresh drywall, how-to and... Of gypsum … stucco drywall is a gypsum-based paste used to make money off a! On a wax application over the years, the three coat plaster system wall is dead and...