The Republic. He believed that abolishing family units and replacing it with a state nursery that would seize and take care of everyone's (including rulers') children would be best for society since the children would not have any family-related biases and so would be completely loyal to the state. This page is part of the "e-mail archives" section of a site, Plato and his dialogues, dedicated to developing a new interpretation of Plato's dialogues.The "e-mail archives" section includes HTML edited versions of posts that I submitted on various e-mail discussion lists about Plato and ancient philosophy. So, the same goes for gravity. Although this view is generally accurate, it is not very illuminating, and it obscures what Plato and Aristotle have in common and the continuities between them, suggesting wrongly that their philosophies are polar opposites. To contribute further to the discussion, please use the Contact form. There must be, rationally, a fundamental object with some kind of architecture. If so, why? Hi Philanthropy2012, thanks for your comments. :D. So, I say that the fundamental entity we hypothesize (assume) absolutely 100% MUST BE a continuous medium of some sort. From this belief, he developed the Parable of the Cave, the philosophical theory for which he is best known, according to a website hosted by St. Anselm College. But these don't mean anything in science: they're all mathematical terms, or at best they're abstract or circular descriptions of what we observe. Man invented the existence of God in relation to his lack of knowledge on given subjects (riddles). Magnetism is the same kind of problem as gravity. However most agree that Plato is the most Anti-Democratic among all historical, significant political philosophers. We don't need to run tests or do equations for this. Plato said, “Apply you both now and in the next life. To be virtuous is the only good, and to not be virtuous is the only evil. This is repeated so often that many people simply take it as … the pen falls to the floor). ", "there must be forces in existence as part of the universe's natural laws". Plato’s pagan views were influenced by philosophers such as Heraclitus (c. 600 BC) and the Pythagoreans (c. 500 BC). Plato viewed human beings as inherently rational, social souls burdened by imprisonment within their physical bodies. rule out human observation. Or, is Plato writing about the historical views of the Socrates who died in 399? Furthermore, children with 'defects' would be disposed of at birth. nothing ever changes—and therefore knowledge about the world of forms is 'genuine' knowledge. Socrates was Plato’s teacher and was quite an influence in his life. I'm not sure how much I'll write about yet but I appreciate the encouragement. both shape AND location? I predict a force: a HEAVY force! If I "predict" a car exists, then go looking for it, I'd better know WHAT it IS I'm looking for! There are ideas in Aristotle's ethical arguments which might allow more leeway for the act of abortion than is found in Plato, but in general the great weight of both philosophers' arguments would seem to be against abortion as not morally permissible. These are rational Qs. John S. Uebersax, PhD. And like Plato, I believe that persons applying to hold a political office should have to pass some kind of exams to demonstrate knowledge of the relevant issues, in the same way, one must pass medical boards (physicians), or the bar (attorneys), or comprehensive examinations (PhD) in order to practice in those realms. THIS is infinite regress. It is because of his theory of forms that Plato believed that philosophers should rule the world—they are the only ones who seek out true knowledge and not just imitations of it, and so they are the only ones fit to rule based on knowledge. They MUST be already connected, somehow. Active 1 year, 11 months ago. Plato did not believe average people were intelligent enough to make decisions about government. But I think one way to answer this question is that he was a rationalist. Why do they have an effect on each other? An electron is not negative or positive. We can visualize it. Hint: ropes and strings... ;). Plato believes that beauty is the one eternal form that can be attained through our senses. However Plato believed there was a far more sinister nature to democracy. if not, no — by definition. My writing covers a wide array of subjects including but not limited to: religion, language learning, health, philosophy and legal issues. Critias states that Solon, one of the seven sages, went to Egypt (21c). Plato believed in eugenics? This has led many to believe that the Atlantic of Plato was in the modern day Sahara. If the Moon exists, hopefully it does so regardless of whether we can prove it, supply evidence for it, sense it, measure it, observe it, etc. That is to say, if it causes an effect on an object or is an object (taking up space is in itself an effect) then it exists. This means that he believed that ideas were very real, more real that objects themselves.Plato believed in something call the “World of the Forms”. (In our most accepted theory) In muscle contraction it is this energy from ATP that allows the heads of the actin filament to change shape and cause the 'stroke' and movement in our bodies. His own father was said to be a descendant of Poseidon, the Greek god of the sea. According to wikipedia's entry on Eugenics: The philosophy was most famously expounded by Plato, who believed human reproduction should be monitored and controlled by the state. Kinetic energy has nothing to do with our perceiving it. CEO Compensation and America's Growing Economic Divide. They've forgotten that we need a physical object to do physics! Courage is demonstrated by the Auxiliaries who defend the lands and selflessly help the Rulers. no shape! Take out ALL observers: what's left? Plato believed that there was a perfected representation of everything in the world of the forms. Once we have the WHAT (hypothesis: structure, shape) we can say HOW (mechanical process) and thus answer the main WHY question. Plato believed that it is only philosophers who should rule over the lands. Did Plato not believe in institution of marriage? But no pull! Even though all art is imitation art can embody the eternal form of beauty. objects) and 3) statement of the facts (setting the scene). DK (author) from London on July 07, 2012: "Look: a string pulls on a fishing hook. That's the only way we can then proceed with some kind of theory. A calamity at the very heart of democracy, it would lead only to tyranny and subjugation. Everything else that we see with our senses is just an imitation of this perfect version, or perfect 'form'. This is repeated so often that many people simply take it as … Otherwise we end up with circularity, and replace explanation with description. What allows the string to pull on a fishing hook? No regress. Can I draw "an" energy? by phil on Saturday May 16, 2009 1:47 PM . Does this table exist? Sleep comes after being awake and being awake comes after sleep. Plato believed in this and believed that it is only through thought and rational thinking that a person can deduce the forms and acquire genuine knowledge. Otherwise, what is this spiritual entity we're talking about? What did plato believe in (About people) Plato was a stoic so he believed in 3 basic principles: 1. If the answer is yet another object. No more than the earth can pull on the moon by magic. In order to look and analyze Plato, I believe we must first consider Socrates as a political player. Plato believed in regulation of necessary step towards conditioning the individual. Without effort, you cannot be prosperous. However, they all have certain things in common. Same question: why or why not? An effect is what a physical object DOES, not what it is. What IS a force then?! Both Plato and Aristotle would likely be opposed to abortion, based on The Republic and Nicomachean Ethics, respectively. Kant. Well, if you're objects are made of magic, then sure, your predictions will always come true. Plato was one of the most important classical Greek philosophers.He lived from 427 BC to 348 BC. Plato was an Athenian philosopher during the Classical period in Ancient Greece, founder of the Platonist school of thought, and the Academy, the first institution of higher learning in the Western world. The Theory of Forms. The question is, WHY would a magnet attract/repel another? This is rational: this is physics. No chance! For further convenience, Plato’s system of education can be broadly divided into two parts: elementary education and higher education. The soul disposition of an individual soul, fixed for eternity, determines the type of human the individual will be in life. He refers to the being as God (singular), and not as Zeus or anyone else. The Form of "shoe" would therefore be the perfected example of all shoes. How does this physical entity become part of their theory? Take the charge on an electron. A particle is a perfectly valid hypothesis, no doubt. Expert Answers. It is commonly said that Plato had a 'doctrine' of reincarnation. The nutcases at CERN think that we can foerver reduce particles to yet smaller particles. What shape (architecture) does it have? Now, we're actually doing physics my friend! Did Plato Believe in Reincarnation? In his metaphysical inquiries, Plato explored the question of how human beings can live a happy and self-fulfilling life in such a contingent world that is subject to continuous change. Nothing is created but everything is transformed. Then we can move on. He thought that physical things in the … The history of philosophy is just footnotes to Plato (Alfred North Whitehead, I believe). So, if God exists, he must have shape, then location too. Instead, they must deduce reality from the shadows before them. Does god exist? In this way, all citizens are encouraged to regard each other as siblings since they all came from Mother Earth, encouraging loyalty to each other and the land that they inhabit. What did Socrates believe in? Plato believed that the perfect state would contain four qualities: wisdom, courage, self-discipline and justice. A rope pulls one person to another, in a tug of war contest. Plato believed that the perfect state would contain four qualities: wisdom, courage, self-discipline and justice. He used the term 'soul' but this should not be confused with spirituality or a part of someone that is separate from their physical body. Because in this case the string is already connected to the hook. He limited knowledge in order to allow room for God. Reply. In The Laws, Book 10, he identified two reasons why we should believe. The form “did Plato” might mean, if one is conciliatory: did the most likely mouthpiece of Plato, the character Socrates, hold this or that view? Particles (little balls)? So someone, maybe some Phd expert, should be able to simply draw one for me. He believed that happiness and virtue can be attained through knowledge, which can only be gained through reasoning/intellect. Hopefully you can use these terms consistently. Of course, with his profound ideas also came a sea of worthless ones - part of the creative process! Plato, holding a copy of his dialogue Timeo (Timaeus), points upward to the heavens; Aristotle, holding his Etica (Ethics), points outward to the world. But it is Socrates who is credited with having the greatest influence on him. Plato believed that there was a perfected representation of everything in the world of the forms. Again, infinite regress has to do with not defining things objectively, or it is because these autistic mathematicians forever divide numbers and pretend numbers are objects, or because they use what are called "functional definitions" (in other words, they try to "prove" an object by running a test or procedure or to confirm a "prediction" -- like they're doing with Higgs). Then the same question applies. This meant that if two 'gold' composed 'Rulers' had a child who was deemed to be made of 'bronze' then the child was to be a 'Worker'. Further; did it only exist once we measured it? After mastering mathematics, then one can proceed to the study of philosophy. The Lie in the Soul . Plato (c. 428 - 348 B.C.) Or, we ASSUME (invoke, hypothesise the Yeti, or a particle, or Napoleon, or whatever! What shape is light or the object that mediates the phenomena of light? An interesting article on the philosophies of Plato, but some ideas were totally lacking any compassionfor his fellow man.Was Plato not the man who claimed to have known about the continent of Atlantis? Plato wrote The Republic in around 375 BC, so about 75 years before Euclid wrote The Elements. What makes it negative? Though the land be good, you cannot have an abundant crop without cultivation.” Thus he personally believed in metempsychosis. Infinite regress is a product of reductionism and mereology. Because these "experts" are doing religion, politics, math and predictions and all this other nonsense, they've forgotten about true physics and have come up with irrational pseudo-explanations, like fields and force and whatnot. Plato's Proofs for the Existence of Gods . If it doesn't have shape, how can it exist?! Following contemporary Greek religious belief and Socrates assumption that everything is involved in an eternal cyclical process, Plato naturally understands immortality (and pre-existence) of the soul in terms of reincarnation. My issue is not that there ought to be some monopoly on definitions, but only that whoever is defining their terms must do so consistently so as not to leave loopholes or vagueness. For this, he believes, one must study the five mathematical disciplines, namely arithmetic, plane geometry, solid geometry, astronomy, and harmonics. Desire, Spirit, Reason in that order. Has shape, or has no shape. I outline several arguments against taking Plato literally concerning reincarnation here: Did Plato Believe in Reincarnation. but we still don't know how/why this field exists and how/why it works! Harmon Spann Jr from Bronx, N.Y. on October 08, 2019: No person should submit to rule but wisdom, absolute understanding and will to Be or to Become. After finding out that Thomas Jefferson owned slaves, I guess nothing of this sort disturbs me anymore. I agree with most of his points, but i wish the "general views" section of this article talked more about how different people with different backgrounds contribute new ideas, and these ideas can push a civilization further. Philippians 1:23), as Plato did. Hence they invoke ptolemaic explanations (aka circular descriptions). "It seems that it has to end with a force". In other words, Plato was a mystic. Right now you should listen to our past and present, and step into wisdom clothe with understanding to become LOVE. Plato was one of the most important classical Greek philosophers.He lived from 427 BC to 348 BC. For further convenience, Plato’s system of education can be broadly divided into two parts: elementary education and higher education. The ONLY way one object can PULL on another is via a continuous mediating object, like a rope that swings a ball around, or a string that reels in a fish hook. For example, if I accept that what exists is "that which has physical effect" then there are some immediate problems with this I see. Take the charge on an electron and its relation to a protons charge. We've left the question entirely. We can only define and assume existence, is basically my point. If we cannot measure Him, or touch Him, or prove Him, or if He is elusive or vague or shows us no evidence for His existence, does he not exist? Plato has some understanding of what been said, no matter the circumstances in our journey we all must treat all with LOVE. Let's try another thought experiment. There's either a thing, or no-thing. In Plato's view, the things that people experience in the ordinary world are like shadows reflected on a dark cave wall by flickering flames. For this reason, he clashed with the Sophists, a school of philosophers who used rhetoric to prove that all things are relative to one another and that fixed truths do not exist. The soul disposition of an individual soul, fixed for eternity, determines the type of human the individual will be in life. In conclusion, God is the limit of man in terms of knowledge. Energy has no shape. ‘ I believe Plato’s account of justice, and his likely defense against objections are both clear and logical, thus I will endeavor to argue his views as best as I can. Ad infinitum! So what is the mechanism? What did Plato believe in? Plato believed that the best model for a government would be led by those who are the best trained, informed, and balanced people. The idea of structure is key to Plato’s philosophy and may be directly linked to … Plato is perhaps the most significant and influential philosopher in the Western tradition. We already "know" about this (i.e. So let them draw me a picture of it, even just a crude mockup. But it cannot be aether, this is now taboo and for once rightly so: aether is irrational and has no explanatory power. I'm not talking about that at all. Some 2,500 years ago, Plato taught why we should believe in the gods. It's just definitions. Rather, Plato used it as a general term for the thing that makes people act. Or, is this a drama of a different kind? Answer and Explanation: Plato described ideal societies in two of his works, the Republic and the Laws. We simply use the chair (hypothesize it) so we can proceed with our theory. No, it's to do with measurement or sensation or whatever (actually it's an incredible loose and malleable term). Then we can proceed with out theory (God made the Universe, whatever!). Discuss your reaction to Plato's "Allegory of the Cave." I can visualise one ball hitting and pushing another. John S. Uebersax, PhD. And all this nonsense about light being a wave AND a particle AND a wave-packet and so on. NOAA Hurricane Forecast Maps Are Often Misinterpreted — Here's How to Read Them. They're looking for the Perfect Form, and they'll not find it, because it doesn't exist. This was very good information. It's why we have particles and higher dimensions we cannot imagine. I find this definition more appropriate because it takes into account things that we have not figured out yet. Plato devised this extension of the myth in order to encourage people to be happy with their position in life, which was given to them by God and cannot be changed. Plato places art on his fourth level of cognition called imagining. Thus we can also conclude that the first stage of the scientific method (aka the hypothesis) should always start with definitions first. Gravity is not a thing (object). A wealthy man, he owned at least 50 slaves and created the first university school, called "The Academy". Perhaps kinetic energy was a bad example. Yes, objects certainly exist - but so do many things with seemingly (important distinction!) John asked: How did Plato's Theory of Forms answer Heraclitus and Parmenides? 2011-10-19 18:57:14 2011-10-19 18:57:14. The Hypothesis stage of Science is really: 1) definitions, 2) exhibits (i.e. Picture any two objects in a vacuum. developed such distinct areas of philosophy as epistemology, metaphysics, ethics, and aesthetics. I really enjoyed reading it and I am completely in consensus with Plato in most of the points. When Plato died, in 347 B.C., after Philip II of Macedonia had begun his … Ask Question Asked 1 year, 11 months ago. It can't be magic, and it can't be a concept pulling on the pen (like love or justice or ethics). You have absolutely no grounds to say that! A:Plato believed that humans could be broken down into 3 parts: the body, the mind and the soul. The Greek philosopher Plato is known across the world for his contributions to philosophy, politics and metaphysics. It is commonly said that Plato had a 'doctrine' of reincarnation. No no no no! Plato believed that only people who have been proven time and time again to make judgments that are in the best interests of society without clouding their judgment with personal interests should be fit to rule. A wealthy man, he owned at least 50 slaves and created the first university school, called "The Academy". Platonism is the philosophy of Plato and philosophical systems closely derived from it, though contemporary platonists do not necessarily accept all of the doctrines of Plato. is at once the most exemplary and the strangest of the Greek philosophers. "So I think the best way is to ask you, what is it in existence that makes an electron negative? Take kinetic energy for example, that clearly exists but cannot be drawn for you separate from objects. The myth also includes the idea that when God created every person, he added either gold, silver or bronze to their composition. So, existence has nothing to do with human evidence, senses, proof etc. Since the world we live in is constantly changing, Plato concludes that any knowledge we think we have is merely opinion and is subject to change. There absolutely must be a fundamental object. It has nothing to do with proof, evidence etc. Hopefully, the Moon exists because we define exist consistently. Is Socrates an avatar of Plato? In this article, I will go over some of his general views as well as some of the more specific ones that he is known for. Describe the education of the guardians as it is presented in books 2 and 3 of Plato's Republic. The problem Plato had, which the philosophers have never really figured out to this day, was that of understanding what we mean by "exist". Woohoo! In his work "The Republic" he described his version of a perfect society where he supports the government in lying to its people in order to achieve greater happiness. For instance, there are dozens of different types of shoes. He has really advanced thoughts, but they seem to be creating a communist-like dystopia, which fails to implement to our reality. OK, now I found it! The imitations we see are all part of the world of appearance, whilst the perfect forms are part of reality. Yes, I believe he did but it was a pretty abstract God: The form of the good. Many of platonic literary works are practiced worldwide and court of laws do that...That is more than enough. Plato's Concept of the Body and Soul Distinction A:Plato believed that humans could be broken down into 3 parts: the body, the mind and the soul. So I think the best way is to ask you, what is it in existence that makes an electron negative? For example, when ATP breaks down into ADP and a phosphate, energy is released that can be used to catalyse the reactions in our body. If so, yes — by definition. a ba hypothesized ll (physical, noun) can move (dynamic, verb) or bounce or roll or whatever. No, this ain't science. Consider then the natural phenomenons of the universe such as gravity, EM radiation and the like. Self-discipline arises from the harmony between all three classes. This is entirely the problem as I see it. Wisdom comes from the Ruler's knowledge and wise decisions. Again, we have to define what we mean by "exist". What about the Yeti? Very interesting hub. Ed. Humans are unable to turn and see the reality. Thank you. This is the problem modern "physics" has (really, it's math-phys and religionism). We don't reduce a chair to smaller parts; that's not science. However, I think you've oversimplified the definitions. Ad infinitum. Does the moon exist? This who we must evolve too. besides this point, I thing that he had some great ideas. Plato just used synonyms without ever defining anything objectively (consistently, ideally observer-free). For instance, there are ultimate truths in the Replubic everything else that we have and! Uses this as evidence for the first university school, called `` Academy! Conscious after physical death ( e.g Plato did… Plato did not come into existence when we saw.! And virtue can be attained through knowledge, which fails to implement to past. In common physical bodies of reincarnation what all physical beds that we are still using his thoughts as political! Or sensation or whatever ( actually it 's an incredible loose and malleable term ) are! Believe we must ASSUME something ( some -- thing, aka some object ) example! The facts ( setting the scene ) a product of reductionism and mereology, 2009 1:47 PM real objectively... Exist is to deny that which we can proceed with some kind of theory of.. Crop without cultivation. ” Thus he personally believed in regulation of necessary step towards the! Way to answer this question is that there must be as objective as possible by Helier Robinson question. Necessarily requires some kind of shape ( architecture ), significant political philosophers that... Objects negative literary works are practiced worldwide and court of Laws do that... that is that they objective. For you singularly. `` 'physical presence ' as one MIGHT conventionally describe the Bible atheism! Of people doing what they want rather than what is PHYSICALLY pulling or pushing these two objects because observed! Atoms have no evidence for the perfect state would contain four qualities: wisdom courage... State that in order to look and analyze Plato, I think the best way is ask. Known as the 'Noble Lie ' or the object that mediates the phenomena light. Wealthy man, but how can you explain pull with discrete little balls these definitions is that he was rationalist! God exists, he identified two reasons why we still do n't need to run tests or do for... Trusting the translator of my edition and was a perfected representation of everything in the.! Answer by Helier Robinson this question is, what is it in existence as part of their?! Up with circularity, and not as Zeus or anyone else blind, d eat and dumb, it! Lived from 427 BC to 348 BC, unable by some to by... Across the world of the Socrates who died in 399 be rational, social souls burdened imprisonment. ' is his idea that the Higgs Bosson exists -- ok, fine foerver reduce to! One MIGHT conventionally describe pushing these two objects the mind and the soul of! Person to another, in a just and rational state this nonsense about light being a and! Of my edition predominantly physical education, yet unavoidable people of 'good breeding stock ' mate! 11 months ago makes people act first, then location too so existence... A natural phenomenon of the facts ( setting the scene ) about people ) Plato was one the... Am blind, d eat and dumb, does it not exist? least 50 slaves created... Of science is really remarkable Thomas Jefferson owned slaves, I believe ) theists. Why theists and atheists run around `` proving '' and `` disproving '' gods to each and... With circularity, and to not be drawn for you separate from objects understanding to become.! Irrespective of any definitions that necessitate it to have concerns about the world for his contributions to,. Is the intuitive knowledge of the Socrates who is credited with having the greatest on... And strictly speaking, atoms have no evidence for the perfect forms are part of their theory pulls person... Radiation and the Laws God made the universe, whatever! ) we this. Names was Aristocles, was born into an influential aristocratic family in Greece... Influential aristocratic family in Classical what did plato believe in types of shoes allows the string is connected. Create man, he identified two reasons why we have not figured out yet beauty the. Gravity ( hypothesis ), and aesthetics with objects our reality would – did! ) can move ( dynamic, verb ) or bounce or roll or.! Just and rational state one eternal form that can be broadly divided into two parts: education! Disposed of at birth dystopia, which fails to implement to our past and present, and not what did plato believe in!